User Tools

Site Tools


math104-f21:final-mistakes

Common Mistakes in Final

1

In general, we don't have an+bn(a+b)na^n + b^n \neq (a+b)^n .

2

Given nan\sum_n a_n converge, and an>0a_n > 0

  • It is wrong to conclude that lim sup(an+1/an))<1\limsup (a_{n+1}/a_n)) < 1.
  • It is wrong to conclude ana_n is decreasing.

3

One need to show that xnx_n is bounded from below; xnx_n is monotone decreasing. These two conditions together show xnx_n converges to some xx. Then one need to prove that x=ax=\sqrt{a}. Missing any of the three steps would make one lose points.

There are other methods to prove this problem, such as creating an auxillary sequence y1=x1,yn+1=(yn+a)/2y_1 = x_1, y_{n+1} = (y_n + \sqrt{a})/2, and show that xnynx_n \leq y_n and ynay_n \to \sqrt{a}.

4

One should start with a Cauchy sequence {fn(x)}\{f_n(x)\} in C(K)C(K), and construct a function f(x)f(x) by taking pointwise limit, define for x[0,1]x \in [0,1], f(x)=limnfn(x)f(x) = \lim_n f_n(x). Thus defined, f(x)f(x) is just a function, and may not be continuous, and we don't know yet fnff_n \to f uniformly or not. Once we show that the convergence is uniform (see solution), then we can use the result that uniform convergence preserve continuity, to conclude that ff is a continuous function on [0,1][0,1], hence fC(K)f \in C(K).

5

If a continuous function f:(0,1)Rf: (0,1) \to \R is unbounded, then it means either limx0f(x)=\lim_{x \to 0} |f(x)| = \infty or limx1f(x)=\lim_{x \to 1} |f(x)| = \infty, since the value of f(p)f(p) is finite for any p(0,1)p \in (0,1). For example, consider the function f(x)=1/x+1/(1x)f(x) = 1/x + 1/(1-x), it is an example of unbounded function (and it is not uniformly continuous).

A common mistake is to say, assume ff is unbounded, then there exists a p(0,1)p \in (0,1), such that limxpf(x)=\lim_{x \to p} f(x)=\infty. That is not what 'unbounded' mean.

6

Some approach is like this,

  • Consider the interval [0,1][0,1], take a global max of f(x)f(x) on [0,1][0,1]. assume it is at x=bx=b.
  • For any u(f(0),f(b))u \in (f(0), f(b)), which is also (f(1),f(b))(f(1), f(b)), there exists a b1(u)(0,b)b_1(u) \in (0,b) and b2(u)(b,1)b_2(u) \in (b,1), such that f(b1(u))=uf(b_1(u)) = u, f(b2(u))=uf(b_2(u))=u.
  • So far the two sentences are correct. But the problem is that, as uf(b)u \to f(b), it is not true that b1(u)bb_1(u) \to b and b2(u)bb_2(u) \to b. (imagine f(x)f(x) has a 'plateau' instead of a 'peak' near x=bx=b). And it is not true that, as one move uu, the function b1(u)b_1(u) and b2(u)b_2(u) varies continuously.

This is an interesting direction, but needs more careful argument to make it work.

7

  • It is tempting to consider f(x)=f(0)+0xf(t)dtf(x) = f(0)+\int_0^x f'(t) dt, however, we don't know if f(t)f'(t) is integrable or not. (-1 point)
  • Even if we assume f(x)f'(x) is integrable, it is wrong to say f(x)dx2dx\int f'(x) dx \leq \int 2 dx . One need to use definite integral.

8

Given A,BA, B compact subset of XX, one need to show that ABA \cap B is compact.

  • If one wants to prove using definition, then one needs to start with an arbitrary open cover of ABA \cap B. Note that this may not be an open cover of either AA or BB.
  • It is a good idea to extend the above open cover to an open cover of AA. For example, by add in the open set BcB^c. Some answer are vague about how to do this extension. If one don't specify the extension, I can throw in an open set that equals to XX, and pick the finite subcover to consist of a single open set, just the added XX.
  • Some answer also write, compact set is equivalent to being closed and bounded. That's false for general metric space XX.
  • Some answer write, “any subset of a compact set is compact”. False, for example (0,1)[0,1](0,1) \subset [0,1].

10

  • Write 12A(x)B(x)dx=12A(x)dx12B(x)dx\int_1^2 \frac{A(x)}{B(x)} dx = \frac{\int_1^2 A(x) dx}{\int_1^2 B(x) dx} .
math104-f21/final-mistakes.txt · Last modified: 2022/01/11 08:36 by pzhou