Daniel ImmerwahrResearch ScholarCommittee on Global Thought Columbia University dsi5@columbia.edu Home page |
Occupy Wall Street: A primer What is the issue? Obviously, this is a large movement with many constituencies. But it seems clear that core concerns include growing income inequality, an increasingly unstable financial sector, and a political system that has allowed both trends to continue. This is not just a protest against capitalism, although for some it is that. It is a protest against recent changes in our political and economic system, changes that have dramatically tilted the playing field. Ivy McDaniel has culled useful graphs and tables from a few sources and compiled them into a very helpful presentation that gives a good sense of the core issues. At the end of that presentation is a timeline that she wrote. A frequent criticism of OWS
is that it is incoherent. Media coverage has focused on
the drum circles, the pageantry, and the more colorful
protesters, often ignoring the substantive claims of
movement. And when the messages of OWS are given attention,
the healthy diversity of positions can sometimes be
mistaken for incoherence. Remember, no political coalition
is ever entirely singing off the same sheet (imagine
trying to extract a core demand from the Republican party,
with its odd amalgamation of evangelical Christianity,
libertarian economic policy, and defense of corporate
privilege). That said, there are a few demands that
capture the main thrust of the movement, in my opinion.
Why occupy? Aren't there other ways to
effect change? What good does sleeping in the park, waving
signs, and yelling do?
Isn't this futile? Don't
powerful interests dominate politics?Occupying parks is only a start. Step one involves drawing the nation's attention to economic issues and building a movement around them. That begins with marches, signs, and conversations. The next steps will require organizing, building long-term institutions, and turning an inchoate movement into effective political action. But the importance of step one should not be dismissed. Social movements can achieve powerful gains--think of the civil rights movement or the attempts to legalize gay marriage. And they are especially necessary at a time when normal political channels are blocked. It is undeniable that our
politicians, Democrats as well as Republicans, have worked
for decades to create this system whereby the richest
members of our society pay surprisingly little in taxes
and experience few constraints on their actions. It is
also hard to deny that this has had a lot to do with the
increasing reliance of politicians on private donations to
finance their campaigns.
What to do?But remember why politicians want money in the first place: to win elections. That means that politicians are still extraordinarily careful when it comes to issues that can gain or lose them votes. The standing bargain is that candidates facing election will pander to voters on the the public issues that everyone follows and cares about (abortion, guns, health care, immigration) and will pander to their backers on issues that voters don't understand or don't care about. The more confusing or hidden from public view an issue is, the more likely it is that politicians will represent their financial rather than their electoral base. Unfortunately, a lot of the rollback of economic regulation, introduction of various loopholes, and trimming of taxes on the richest one percent has taken the form of complicated legislation that few voters understand or follow. Occupy Wall Street puts politicians on notice: we are watching. If you continue to tilt the playing field in favor of the rich, we are going to call you out. If, on the other hand, you introduce or back substantive legislation that responds to our demands, you will have an active, energized base upon which to draw--a base that has shown itself to be capable of putting hundreds of thousands of people in the streets. The most important thing
right now is to increase the visibility of Occupy Wall
Street and its sibling movements. So visit the parks, put
up signs, wear buttons, write "We are the 99%" on your
money, talk to people, join one of the many actions taking
place online and in your city, sign petitions, write
articles, and so forth.
One thing that is particularly important is for people who do not fit the standard model of a protester to get visibly involved. That means teachers, lawyers, professors, businesspeople, professionals, and so forth. The media is drawn to drummers with body paint screaming half-baked ideas at the top of their lungs and antagonizing the police. We cannot let that be the whole of this movement. So put on some business clothes, put your kids in a stroller, make a sign, and get down there--in between the cameras and the crazy--and help broaden this movement. |