Defendant: Shimodaira, Naozo, Civilian Guard employed by Nippon Kokan Kobushiki Kaisha, plant located near Tokyo Area PW Detached Camp No. 5

Docket No./ Date: 49/July 10-12, 1946, Yokohama, Japan

Charge: Violation of the laws and customs of war: 1. Did unlawfully beat and cruelly torture American PWs.

Specifications: beatings using leather belt, bamboo stick, rubber hose, wooden ruler, riding crop, and clubs; torture by burning

Verdict: 12 years CHL

Reviewing Authority's Recommendations: Accused was employed at the plant where prisoners from Tokyo Area PW Detached Camp No. 5 were required to work. Accused was nicknamed "Josephine" and was identified as being responsible for the beatings and torture of specified PWs.

Reviewing Authority: Denied beatings and torture of certain individuals. Stated that he was absent when another alleged incident happened. He admitted striking four PWs but they were as punishment for stealing food and on one occasion for molesting a woman at the factory.

Prosecution Arguments: The record is legally sufficient to support the findings. The evidence supports the findings beyond a reasonable doubt. There was no evidence that the accused was not sane at the time of the alleged acts or at the time of trial.

Defense Arguments: Cyril D. Hill, Lt. Col. Assistant Staff Judge Advocate

Judge Advocate's Recommendations: Lt. Col. Allan R. Browne, Army Judge Advocate found that "in view of the compelling evidence of many and protracted tortures committed by each accused," the sentence was inadequate.