Author |
Topic: Re: Sleeping Beauty (Read 4342 times) |
|
Icarus
wu::riddles Moderator
Uberpuzzler
Boldly going where even angels fear to tread.
Gender: 
Posts: 4863
|
 |
Re: Sleeping Beauty
« on: Apr 8th, 2003, 4:58pm » |
|
on Apr 8th, 2003, 4:30pm, THUDandBLUNDER wrote:On every occasion that he awakens her she is first injected with a drug that causes complete memory loss; he then awakens her, explains the situation to her, and asks her how much credence she gives to the proposition that the coin came up heads.
...
Are you a halfer or a thirder? |
|
I am a "If she has complete memory loss, how is she going to understand his question, much less make any sense of it and figure out an answer?"-er.
|
| « Last Edit: Apr 8th, 2003, 5:00pm by Icarus » |
 IP Logged |
"Pi goes on and on and on ...
And e is just as cursed.
I wonder: Which is larger
When their digits are reversed? " - Anonymous
|
|
|
Icarus
wu::riddles Moderator
Uberpuzzler
Boldly going where even angels fear to tread.
Gender:
Posts: 4863
|
|
Re: Sleeping Beauty
« Reply #1 on: Apr 8th, 2003, 5:09pm » |
|
on Apr 8th, 2003, 4:30pm, THUDandBLUNDER wrote:If the result is heads he awakens her on Tuesday; if tails, he awakens her on both Tuesday and Wednesday.
... there are three possible occasions upon which she can be awakened with equal probability... |
|
Did you perhaps mean he would wake her on both wednesday and thursday for tails?
|
|
IP Logged |
"Pi goes on and on and on ...
And e is just as cursed.
I wonder: Which is larger
When their digits are reversed? " - Anonymous
|
|
|
aero_guy
Senior Riddler
Gender:
Posts: 513
|
|
Re: Sleeping Beauty
« Reply #2 on: Apr 8th, 2003, 6:46pm » |
|
The way you currently have the question worded he will explain the situation to her, meaning she knows what day it is. If the day she awakens is Tuesday then she has to make a 50/50 guess. If the day is Wednesday she knows with 100% accuracy. Since she knows what day it is you can't really combine these results into an overall probability.
If it is Tuesday she has a 50/50 shot. If it is Wednesday she knows for certain.
If you interpret the wording that she has no idea what day it is, than I am a halfer. Again, you cannot combine the probabilities in a normal way. Look at the case where she is woken up 99 times with tails. The problem comes in determining the total possible outcome. Even with 99 tail wake ups there are still only two scenarios.
|
| « Last Edit: Apr 8th, 2003, 6:53pm by aero_guy » |
IP Logged |
|
|
|
aero_guy
Senior Riddler
Gender:
Posts: 513
|
|
Re: Sleeping Beauty
« Reply #3 on: Apr 8th, 2003, 7:12pm » |
|
Hmm, on second thought, I think there may be some difficulty in interpreting the question, "how much credence she gives to the proposition that the coin came up heads."
If this were a game we were to play several times and you bet a dollar each time you awoke on tails, them 50% of the time you would lose a dollar and 50% of the time you would win two, for a net increase of $1, which seems to state there is a 100% chance of it being tales, odd. As I was getting at before, this differs from a standard probability riddle in that you are really dealing with a base of more than 100%. You have a 50% chance there will be a heads wake up, a 50% chance there will be a first tales wake up, and a 50% chance there will be a second tales wake up, for a total of 150%.
So, IMO, the way the riddle is stated it is 50%, but if we play this game a bit and I am asked what is my bet to maximize profits, I go with tails.
|
|
IP Logged |
|
|
|
towr
wu::riddles Moderator
Uberpuzzler
Some people are average, some are just mean.
Gender:
Posts: 13730
|
|
Re: Sleeping Beauty
« Reply #4 on: Apr 8th, 2003, 11:43pm » |
|
the question isn't wether it was heads or tails, but wether it was heads or tails given that she was awoken.
She is always awoken, but 1/3 of the time she is awoken when it was heads, and 2/3 she was awoken when it was tails.
So Bayes makes me a thirder..
Also it is clear to see that on average she's awoken 3 times per two coin tosses. Once for head, twice for tails.
|
|
IP Logged |
Wikipedia, Google, Mathworld, Integer sequence DB
|
|
|
Chronos
Full Member
Gender:
Posts: 288
|
|
Re: Sleeping Beauty
« Reply #5 on: Apr 9th, 2003, 7:57pm » |
|
Quote:| If this were a game we were to play several times and you bet a dollar each time you awoke on tails, them 50% of the time you would lose a dollar and 50% of the time you would win two, for a net increase of $1, which seems to state there is a 100% chance of it being tales, odd. |
|
No, this just indicates that "even money" is not the right odds for this bet. If the casino let me make an even money bet that the roulette wheel won't come up 00, then I'd make a profit off of that, too, but that doesn't mean that there's a 100% chance that the wheel won't be 00.
I say that the answer (from Slumbering Lovely's perspective) is 1/3.
|
|
IP Logged |
|
|
|
rmsgrey
Uberpuzzler
    
Gender:
Posts: 2873
|
|
Re: Sleeping Beauty
« Reply #6 on: Jul 24th, 2003, 3:23am » |
|
In puzzles like this, I often find it helps to consider modified cases, so without further ado, what I call the Arabian version:
As the original, except that Sheherazade takes part in the experiment. Rather than sleeping for 1001 nights (and being woken up each day if the coin came up heads) instead she simply has her memory of the previous day wiped each day, and on the first day is required to tell a story. On subsequent days she is only required to tell a story if the coin came up tails.
I guess I should probably hide the rest of this in case anyone is still trying to decie which side they're on...
::
It seems to me that the real problem lies in how you incorporate the fact she's required to tell a story (or woken up in the original) - which provides additional information. If she isn't required to tell a story (or wasn't woken up) she knows (or would if awake) the coin came up heads. The fact that hasn't happened means that there is additional information.
I think the correct solution is to consider the situation as the product of two independent uniformly distributed random variables: the coin toss and the day. In the original, there are four possible outcomes (2002 in the Arabian) all of which are equally probable - Tu/H, Tu/T, We/H and We/T of which We/H can be ruled out by circumstance. A common mistake in probability questions is to overlook the cases that don't arise.
An alternative question to try and help the unconvinced: if you knew about the experiment, and knew she was being woken up for an hour at noon on those days she was being awoken, but forgot whether it was being run so heads had her woken up on the Tuesday or the Wednesday, what credence would you give to the proposition that you would find her awake if you dropped in at half past midday?
::
|
|
IP Logged |
|
|
|
turtler7
Newbie
Gender:
Posts: 37
|
|
Re: Sleeping Beauty
« Reply #7 on: Aug 20th, 2003, 7:32am » |
|
Reading through this I dont know that anyone said whay feelings I have on it.
As in all riddles there is generally extra info to get you off track. Which when modified only to contain needed info it would say this
"Sleeping Beauty agrees to participate in an experiment. On Monday she is put to sleep and the scientist conducting the experiment then tosses a (fair) coin. He then awakens her, explains the situation to her, and asks her how much credence she gives to the proposition that the coin came up heads."
Which as always with probability to a coin flip it is 1/2. The extra times being awakened is only there to get you off track. The question is simple matter of heads or tails. Not its tuesday and it was heads, tuesday and tails, wendsday and tails. It was not asked that way. Only the probability of a coin flip is asked.
|
|
IP Logged |
|
|
|
towr
wu::riddles Moderator
Uberpuzzler
Some people are average, some are just mean.
Gender:
Posts: 13730
|
|
Re: Sleeping Beauty
« Reply #8 on: Aug 20th, 2003, 7:58am » |
|
No, not the probability of the coinflip being heads is asked, but the probability of the coin flip being heads given that sleeping beauty is woken up.
There's a subtly yet important difference there.
Suppose they put her under for a years, and flip a coin, if it's tails they wake her up januari first, if it's heads they wake her up every day of the year.
So now sleeping beauty is awoken and asked what's the chance the coin flip was heads?
on average she'll be woken up every day of the year one year, and just januari first the next. So chances are when sh'es woken up the coin was heads.
|
|
IP Logged |
Wikipedia, Google, Mathworld, Integer sequence DB
|
|
|
turtler7
Newbie
Gender:
Posts: 37
|
|
Re: Sleeping Beauty
« Reply #9 on: Aug 20th, 2003, 8:03am » |
|
THUDandBLUNDER can likly clear it up... I see your point and thats why he listed both but I still go with just regular probability as the answer. He has seceded and making u think harder than is nessasary. I could be off i dont say im right nessasarilly but this is my veiw and y it is most likly in my mind set.
|
|
IP Logged |
|
|
|
rmsgrey
Uberpuzzler
Gender:
Posts: 2873
|
|
Re: Sleeping Beauty
« Reply #10 on: Aug 20th, 2003, 9:38am » |
|
A question for the 'halfers': if SB doesn't wake up, how much credence should she give to the proposition that the coin came up heads?
OK, so that doesn't quite work, but suppose instead of letting her sleep on Wednesday if the coin came up Heads, the researcher awakens her and tells her that the coin came up Heads. After all the key point of the puzzle is that SB knows that she isn't in the position where it's Wednesday and the coin came up heads...
Another variation: After reading this paragraph to two people, I put them in separate (isolated) rooms and then toss a coin. If the coin comes up Heads, I toss it a second time to randomly pick one of the two people to ask which way up they think the coin landed. If it comes up Tails, I ask both of them. What should they guess, and what is their chance of being right?
|
|
IP Logged |
|
|
|
turtler7
Newbie
Gender:
Posts: 37
|
|
Re: Sleeping Beauty
« Reply #11 on: Aug 20th, 2003, 12:42pm » |
|
Their best guess is tails. As if they are asked then its more likly to be tails. Although in this above senario there are not two people. Just diferent days. She doesnt know the day or if she has been asked before. She has to be asked 100% So the guess only has tails and heads are options making it 50/50. The senario doesnt fit the same as yours. If it was the same I would agree with the 33% heads 66% tails. But it is not that way. I see how it is confusing, but I dont see how it would not accually BE 50/50.
|
|
IP Logged |
|
|
|
towr
wu::riddles Moderator
Uberpuzzler
Some people are average, some are just mean.
Gender:
Posts: 13730
|
|
Re: Sleeping Beauty
« Reply #12 on: Aug 20th, 2003, 1:10pm » |
|
do it a million times..
on average she's woken up 1.5 times per week, twice on average per two weeks when it's tails, once per two weeks on average when it's heads.
|
|
IP Logged |
Wikipedia, Google, Mathworld, Integer sequence DB
|
|
|
James Fingas
Uberpuzzler
Gender:
Posts: 949
|
|
Re: Sleeping Beauty
« Reply #13 on: Aug 20th, 2003, 1:20pm » |
|
What we are asking Sleeping Beauty to calculate is the probability that a head was flipped. If she (or he) is smart, the she (or he) will calculate the probability given that she (or he) was awakened.
Bayes will give us the straightforward answer here:
p(heads given awakened) = p(heads and awakened)/p(awakened)
Obviously there are two possible days on which Sleeping Beauty can be awakened, and two possible values for the coin. We'll assume that tails happen as often as heads, and that Tuesdays happen as often as Wednesdays:
p(heads and Tuesday) = 1/4
p(heads and Wednesday) = 1/4
p(tails and Tuesday) = 1/4
p(tails and Wednesday) = 1/4
Therefore:
p(heads and awakened) = p(heads and Tuesday) = 1/4
p(awakened) = p(heads and Tuesday) + p(tails and Tuesday) + p(tails and Wednesday) = 3/4
p(heads given awakened) = (1/4)/(3/4)
p(heads given awakened) = 1/3
No doubt about it ... Bayes is a thirder! And with that recommendation, I'm a thirder too 
|
|
IP Logged |
Doc, I'm addicted to advice! What should I do?
|
|
|
James Fingas
Uberpuzzler
Gender:
Posts: 949
|
|
Re: Sleeping Beauty
« Reply #14 on: Aug 20th, 2003, 1:29pm » |
|
Here's another formulation that doesn't require amnesia:
Bill, an evil customers of your company's, will flip a coin. If he gets heads, he'll call you at home for product support on Saturday. If he gets tails, he'll call you on Sunday. Ned, another evil customer, will do likewise.
Early Saturday morning, one of these two morons calls you. What are the odds they flipped the same thing?
The probability is 1/3 here as well.
|
|
IP Logged |
Doc, I'm addicted to advice! What should I do?
|
|
|
aero_guy
Senior Riddler
Gender:
Posts: 513
|
|
Re: Sleeping Beauty
« Reply #15 on: Sep 23rd, 2003, 6:21am » |
|
James,
Sorry to jump back at this so long after your last post, but I have a problem with the last thing you said. I don't think your evil customers are like the OP as you are given the information that one of them called you, and you know what day it is. This tells you one of them flipped heads. They are no longer part of the problem. The only question now is did the other. Though I agree with the 1/3 for the original problem, I do not see how this relates.
|
|
IP Logged |
|
|
|
James Fingas
Uberpuzzler
Gender:
Posts: 949
|
|
Re: Sleeping Beauty
« Reply #16 on: Sep 23rd, 2003, 8:19am » |
|
I had to change the puzzle slightly so it didn't require amnesia. In the reformulation, as soon as they call you on Saturday, you know that they couldn't both have flipped tails. There are three equally likely possibilities remaining, and only one of those three has them flipping the same thing.
|
|
IP Logged |
Doc, I'm addicted to advice! What should I do?
|
|
|
aero_guy
Senior Riddler
Gender:
Posts: 513
|
|
Re: Sleeping Beauty
« Reply #17 on: Sep 23rd, 2003, 8:35am » |
|
Ah, they key to that being the same is that you are asking the question when you hear the phone ring, before you pick it up (and therefore know who it was). Does this mean that the act of hearing who it was who called you reduces the chance of them both having flipped heads to 50/50? That would be quite odd.
|
|
IP Logged |
|
|
|
James Fingas
Uberpuzzler
Gender:
Posts: 949
|
|
Re: Sleeping Beauty
« Reply #18 on: Sep 23rd, 2003, 9:16am » |
|
on Sep 23rd, 2003, 8:35am, aero_guy wrote:| Does this mean that the act of hearing who it was who called you reduces the chance of them both having flipped heads to 50/50? |
|
I don't think so. Even after the phone call, all you know is that at least one person flipped heads. The key to these types of questions (e.g. the one I asked, the one head/two head question, Monty Hall, age of death of rock stars, the original question in this thread, etc.) is the statistical problem of "self selection" (maybe that's not exactly what it's called, but I'm too lazy to Google).
"Self selection" is where your measurement system implicitly prefers a certain result, either by over-reporting (the key to Sleeping Beaty), or by not allowing certain results (the key to the one head/two head question, Monty Hall, and most others). This dramatically affects the probabilities. Basically, you are fooled into thinking that what was a uniform probability distribution is still uniform, when in fact the measurement system has already changed the results.
The way to analyze a problem like this is to look at the probability as a probability given the stated measurement system. Using Bayes' theorem, you just add up the probabilities of the various outcomes, keeping in mind how much each outcome would tend to get measured.
[edit] I just realized that I never said how self-selection is relevant to this problem. Examining whether a specific one of the two calls you on Saturday is only useful if you pick that person before they call. As soon as he call you, he has picked himself. [/edit]
|
| « Last Edit: Sep 23rd, 2003, 1:03pm by James Fingas » |
IP Logged |
Doc, I'm addicted to advice! What should I do?
|
|
|
rmsgrey
Uberpuzzler
Gender:
Posts: 2873
|
|
Re: Sleeping Beauty
« Reply #19 on: Sep 23rd, 2003, 9:17am » |
|
on Sep 23rd, 2003, 8:35am, aero_guy wrote:| Does this mean that the act of hearing who it was who called you reduces the chance of them both having flipped heads to 50/50? That would be quite odd. |
|
No odder than in the "not both girls" problem, where seemingly trivial differences in phrasing the puzzle change the probability of both children being boys from 1/3 to 1/2... In fact, the two problems are very closely related - though Sleeping Beauty's phrasing seems rather more robust.
|
|
IP Logged |
|
|
|
|
RIDDLES SITE
WRITE MATH!
Home 
Help 
Search 
Members 
Login 
Register
Notify of replies
Send Topic
Print